Showing posts with label critic. Show all posts
Showing posts with label critic. Show all posts

Monday, July 13, 2009

Fire emblem General Rant part 4


We go straight to n°9, Fire emblem Path of Radiance.
For those who don't know about who the guy in my avatar is I'll enlighten you and say its' the main character of this game for the gamecube, Ike.
Before I start ranting anything about plot, story, characters, upgrades, settings, and so on, I want to say, as much as many out there didn't like the idea of a wide screen fire emblem where the characters looked always too solemn and seriuos for their liking this fire emblem has marked my liking to the series.
With no longer adue I'll say why it's like this.
The first title of the series on the gamecube, not to mention it's origin was pretty late compared to other games. Path of Radiance has in my opinion a great plot, sure, the beginning will look shabby and incredibly dull and you'll be questioning if the buy was worth it. As mentioned in the first part of this ranting fire emblem was for me known as a book where you are able to see your units do their stuff, whoever doesn't like the idea of a something like this dedicated to be in a small screen rather than a LG it's perfectly fine with me, though, I have to say, the variety in gaming is always fun at some point.
In general, the story is well sorted and at times awkward but not annoying positions, as an example the sometimes placement of Ike in cleary too high positions interaction (his company involvement with royalty etc), I have nothing agaisnt it actually.
One of the best points of the game, in my personal opinion, is the characters. Sure, many already got used to the bland things of a common GBA pixeled dialogue, with no intention of offense, I found much more appealing and entertaining the interactions in the gamecube game, I guess I couldn't be satisfied with the GBA versions.

Ike not being a nobleman didn't much appeal to me in the beginning, as the story goes on I kept my eyes keen in his role as a commoner charging through different places and stages, it was what I considered interesting.
Of course, this kind of maneuver couldn't be done with lame dialogues, the interaction between characters are fair enough decent and the storyline itself rows smoothly and in ease.
I will try and not spoil anything so let's see, why do I like Ike so much? I find him the best fire emblem character ever made, it's not neccesarily because of his common blue hair with generic features of a rough boy (which isn't appealing to me at all) and this defying and taking different paths from the usual prince, but his development and personality, hell, his resolution and general interaction are for me well achieved.
You might notice I'm not asking much from a character, a solid and shapeable personality was enough for me to feel satisfied.
You'll get as the usual series more and more to your mary band of mercenaries and I have to say, still belonging the character area, Ike is not the only one with some personality.
I use as example the sniper Shinon whom in my opinion deal pretty well with his sarcastic, aloof and general attitude, at least I could re call these traits juts by looking at his character art.
It's not a surprise to question how the heck did Titania or Oscar got their armors so polished and so on, I couldn't answer this apart from saying 'it's fire emblem characters', 'the good guys will always be pretty to look at.'
We have as another added point the two distinct live forms; the humans who look human (beorcs: your usual units in the pre games) and the humanoids that posses a common characteristic from a animal (laguz), indeed, I have no doubt that at some point the producers were nervous of how this would turn on, adding humanoid animals into the realm of fire emblem, these characters are nothing lower of interesting than the general entirely human looking, in fact, most of them have much more personality than most of the usual looking units. This part is pretty tight with the upgrade section so it'll have to wait till then.
So as a sum up of this section, I say the variety of characters is relatively satisfactory, you'll see a nice and sweet princess from a rotting old man.
I repeat myself, the beginning is not near of how interesting it gets further on.

Not only is the character part well done but the setting is nicely output.
A band of goodie toes mercenaries that get involved in the whole continent bussiness Telius. With a decent and not entirely useless narration you get a well set up of where you are and why, it was pretty clear if you ask me.
Something I've waited since the beginning since character mentioning is the satisfactory spread of 'races' across the land, the laguz being south east from the other countries and kinda stick to each other seperated by frontiers.
It's in general a really fun world to look at, the setting seems simple and it's definately a world where I'd expect much. This last said points alot to what the producers did, even though Path of Radiance was a fun game where when finishing it you'd say 'it was fun,' you were undoubtly awaiting for more laguz beorc action, I mean, the whole main plot revolves around talking about a huge war and how much it must be stopped, sure, it is stopped (at this point I guess spoiler advertisement is futile) but you still want the huge calamity to strike as a gamer, as much as you pity all the people in there.
You'll get this last satiated in the sequel and that's what I'm mostly gonna talk about in the last part of my ranting.
Something to say before ending this part is that I found really fun the way each beorc and laguz generally see each other, sure, their general behaviors to each other are extremely expected but further than that I liked the idea of the insults 'human' and 'sub human', this last one in specific because it simply remarks the fact that their world has granted the laguz (sub human) less 'intelligence' than the beorcs (human) but have all general animal advantages as to instincts. Yes, in general I liked the whole concept.

Unit mannagement on the big screen was sure, big and 3d, kinda different from the usual pixels, many simply didn't buy the game because of the idea and other probably cut gaming because of the concept, I'm in the people who kept of playing because of the story and general curiosity.
Something that's out of the question though is that, of course, we were expecting much more than what was presented to us, a whole change scene for a strike o counter strike, no doubt the big screen makes it look like a mini movie in the beginning but later on it's a plain drag, of course you can just switch it off but improvement in that area would be highly apreciated, the game is after all a whole spin off from the usual series, why not make it? Of course, changing this one and one fight scene would mean great general changes in the usual combat area on whom I haven't actually sorted it out yet.
Something that wasn't so alarming neither TOO attention seeking was the dissapearence of some of the classes, why not so alarming? You have a whole bunch of laguz to cover up such, besides, not thinking so much in deph about the matter I'd conclude the creators were thinking something for making it like that, well, whatsoever I'm just one of the many gamers that play it.
The incorporation of other beings instead of the classic humans agaisnt humans was highly appealing to me, sure, the idea at first sounds vague and you'd many times question (if you were interested to begin with) if that's the best they could do about new ideas, I myself found it great, why so fun you ask? Because it makes each other remark themselves as the story unfolds to new series of events where each of them have a role somehow, besides, the laguz personalities are simply more true to what a animal would be if it took a humanoid form. From this last, people who aren't much of a fan or simply are but bugs them at some point, there could be questions of why they should take a human form and why should they be so 'human ish' if their 'true' forms are animals, to tell you truth, it's something on which I haven't thought much, till now I have simply enjoyed the fact there are other races apart from humans and that have things on which I can generally distinguish one and another, the game doesn't make it annoying.
Something from the technical part that is effective and at the same time not is the skill part, that's that.
You'll get a pumping intro and a decent character art if only some of them weren't so yelling in color.
Apart from the connection with characters and setting, the upgrade stands too on what is cinematography, sure, it isn't purely dissapointing and terribly bad, but damn Mists' voice annoys me and damn I prefer imagining Ike talking than actually hearing his english voice, it's simply retarded for me, the only save-able person is Ike's father and the singing part in the Serenes forest.


You'll get the usual fire emblem dialogue interaction, be it semi body showing or sprite field which is clearly something a fire emblem gamer would have expected more development or simply is satisfied and not molested with the 'improvements', personally, it wasn't such a bother and yet I always found myself expecting more in this upgrading media area.



In conclusion about this game I say it's the fire emblem whom, if you are open and a reader will enjoy much, sounds extremly vague and generic but I have no other way to say how you would like this. I personally did and till now would remmember things from the game, un questionably Ike and how he develops. The game itself isn't the best thing since best but then again no fire emblem game was pretty much in that area, it was for me always a chilling way to pass a quiet evening, just reading and going through the story with characters I like to get attached with.

Final scores

Story: 8.5/10


Characters: 9/10


Setting: 8/10


Upgrade: 7.5/10


Total: 33/40



"A fair playing fire emblem that, even if you haven't played the previuos ones, you'll fairly enjoy the story. The wide screen is something that has pros and cons, yet again, it's something to simply deal with."

Fire emblem General Rant part 3


If you ever did wonder the avatar here is based on a wallpaper on which I extracted the main figure and made a 100x100 pimped square, I have that truthfully in mind and I'm not hoping for community chaos because of such.

Carrying on we the evaluation we have n°8, Fire emblem Sacred Stones.
From where to begin... ok I got a reasonable set up, the story is boring and just plain none epic, I have no idea if the creators thought that fire emblems' good points were not incluiding the story or character development but its' easy to see there was no appeal in this area. Sure, it isn't as bad as n°6 and the map we are given too is far more dark and arcane (it's highlight) and yet I can't remmember anything from this game apart from having a none interesting relationship between two perfect abricombie finch models, hell I remmember their names Erika and Ephraim, I have to say, the name of the guy took my eyes instantly.
The setting could have been much more well done, I mean, just look at the continent and all the dark loomers around, of course, being a fire emblem game at heart they decided on the 'epic' win over all darkness and evil having to behold such radiating and boring brotherly love.
Sure, the upgrads seem to have been one of the center points of the producers, the art posses a really nice clean painting ish render and the chap advancing is no longer one head line as it has been till now, no ladies and gentlemen, here you can travel as you please through the continent, in other words, probably many complaints reached the creator ears and so they decided on doing the most easy and logical solution, traveling at will from poit to point where you have two ways; one being the one you already beated up so you could continue to the next and the other where the story would press on.
This is the overview you get each time you beat a stage or dot, this example just showing the the beginning;


















It's clear to see they totally turned their attention to this upgrading part where you could lvl up and have the chance to select one of two classes for each member and gave out a rather cold shoulder to the other two points of story and characters, sure, the characters are not so bad and yet from what I could remmember never did attach myself to any of them, apart from the nice name Ephraim.
In short words, what could I say about the story? It's none attractive, predictable and boring, given the world and the characters I would have expected much more from the story line.
This last points to our character development area which is in simple words for me not-bad, true, the water colors and the rather dark shading is pretty appealing for gamers of fire emblem but their general blandness and none interesting pick ups leave them as they are right now in my opinion of boring.
The characters, apart from looking pretty and nice, decent if that's the word, could have been much more versatil, I mean, just look at the swordsgirl Marisa or Marica, she's supposed to be a cold and extremely dedicated swordsperson and she looks like she just got out of celebrity cocktails where every woman would gossip of how hot and none hot everybody looked, seriuosly, those boots are pretty high-heeled for me if its' for someone so not into the fashion world.
I know every character till now in fire emblem has high class taste in clothing and I have nothing agaisnt it, it's just these specific characters that I find myself doubtful and questioning if it's really true they have such and attitude or if they are just pretending for the hell of it.
Not all of them in this game are terrible, I mean, there's a mercenary with a buff body and a decent scar that clings to the word 'street wise', a dancer named Thetys or tetys that has mentioned at some point of how much she takes care of herself, a rather decent looking archer that looks seriuos, it's not all that bad, it's just, as mentioned earlier, a pity they didn't press much of the story and the characters in such a wide setting to tribute the great name of 'game developement'-Upgrades, not to mention those others that are equivalent to a turn off, ahem, girl beside this text.
Believe me, this is a good example of swirling hair beneath the rays of sun and across the 'bloody' mad war where dark creatures roam and want nothing but flesh, thanks but, I've had quite enough with that.
True, the other fire emblems have the same thing going and I haven't mentioned it till now and that's for a reason; these heroines have no personality whatsoever to explain their use of hair for that, it just leaves me believe they like looking pretty which has nothing wrong to it, if they could (Marisa) keep up with their attitude or at least personality that is.
I pretty much know fire emblem is about pretty people slaying the evil doors and I've liked it so far, but sometimes you just have the neccesity to question and be doubtful about their appearences and ways, if you have never thought about it and have nothing pulling down your interests about the matter, I recomend you this game, that is if you're ready for fair boring story telling.
Something that by this extent you've been probably wondering is the battle part, yes, in this game you are agaisnt not only bad people but bad monsters from Evil Von Dark, that's how you keep on killing and killing and lvl uping, this takes part from the upgrade section. Another point of this area is the general human a monster relationships, they sure try to make it as tight and not soffocating as possible, this is something I can't consider bad or good, it's pure taste.
In conclusion, the game is none epic and none memorable, it's bland in the area beyond pretty faces and nice coloring with a decent map, even if the creators unleashed all what the common sense would say they should have unleashed in the upgrading part it sometimes turns out to be a downfall because it doesn't feel as wanted as what the gamers wanted in the start.




Final scores:

Story: 5/10

Characters: 6.5/10 (just because they have Ephraim with a lance called reingleif and a decent art)

Setting: 7/10

Upgrade: 6.5/10

Total score: 25/40



"Enjoyable to an extent. Because of lacking appeal in story and character the game turns repetitive and none original."

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Fire emblem General Rant part 1


By Phantom:

There are things that are a must if a fire emblem wants my attention; Storyline, characters, setting(world and map) and upgrades (classes, races, self incertation, etc specified later on), if one of these 4 aspects are lacking developement or simply isn't put, the game for me stands as a failure of the series.
So as you can guess, I'll score each of the ones I've played and get a total sum up.



Not long ago I played again through FE Radiant Dawn for the Wii and of course, because I am pretty much into the story of the Path of Radiance one the continuation was warmly cuddled as I was wide-eyed open to any new pop outs of the storyline.


This last said, fire emblem in general is a pictured comic where the dialogue (and time to time ilustrations) is the only way to understand what is going on, in other words, if you like reading chances are high you'll like the series.


I must say, if your not a fan or simply didn't play the first Fire emblem for the gamecube (Path of Radiance) I'll place my bets you'll sell it to the nearest gamestop or black market. As best example for this I have an aquaintance whom I probably (don't remmember) crashed about how fun the game was after going it through the first time, as a result she bought the game and found herself utterly in dissapointment, pity I forgot she never played any of the "strategy", which consists in having your allies as strong as you can, originally portable game.
Sure, there are alot of critics about not only the game Radiant Dawn itself but the creation of the block unit selection in the widescreen instead of something Wii sportish or Twilight princessish, truth is, as much as I have liked both big screen fire emblems the effectiveness in my opinion takes its' role when being portable, as a matter of fact, the first release of the series directed itself to the GBA and till now many preffer the older series than the recent one.




Because I have the time and the interest to I'll rank them up critic in a not deep lengh each fire emblem I've played, starting from 6 with Roy.

I've played from the 6th to the 10th and it'd be hard to rank them up, aside from the 6th (which is definately last from the 5) 7 and 9 are drabbleing for the 1st place.
The fifth is what everybody wanted after playing SSBM and taking a liking in Roy is our boy, sure, the only thing out in the
market was somebody slightly more grown up than the red haired boy on the box ilustration spotlight and you could give it a try, but heck, we all simply wanted to play somebody we 'knew' about. The game is simply terrible and dissapointing, apart from being a entire bore were Edipo would have probably done something more interesting to change fates the games' story and characters were as instantly imagined and thought as if I had my eyes closed instead of focusing on the dialogue or anything fire emblem charming.
The story was never appealing to me nor the characters were remmembered after beating it as soon as I could, sure, it has our Roy beaing the center guy but believe me, characters such as link are really pretty to see with no dialogue, EXCUUUUUUSE what I said if any out there actually liked the things Roy drabbled from his pixeled mouth but it's just plain to see, the conversations were a entire bore, sure, I've only played to translated version by pc and what I read wasn't concetrated to annoy you (to the extent of making it dull) but that still really doesn't cover much the character design and general boredom area. In summary, which is a fire emblem with a entirely boring setting and world? It's Fire emblem the Sword of Seals from what I know and conclude. Why is it so boring? The characters are not appealing nor interesting (not neccesarily looking), and the story is highly predictable and development in this area is poor, the upgrade point mentioned earlier is not that bad, I haven't played any before fire emblem to make a comparison so that's out of my judgement, what I could probably conclude is that the class changing and stuff was pretty awesome news back then and the portable idea is great till now.
The only positive remark I can point out is the setting which shares the world with its' daddy in the storyline(blazing sword which appears later), though, if generally comparing both, blazing sword makes it much more interesting and fun to read and be interested at the world and general setting, a point I can remmember why my opinion stands like this is the way they create the gamers' link to their world more stronger, an example for this to happen is the map short drabbles or cities intros, stuff like that.

Score gives:

Story: 3/10

Characters: 4/10

Setting: 4/10

Upgrade: 7.5/10

Total: 18.5/40